Add Threaded Or Nested Comments To WordPress
WordPress has recently added new comment functionality to the core. You can now show nested or threaded comments. The feature I really like about it is the ability to directly reply to a comment or question on a post. Unfortunately for the reply to show directly under the comment you need to either tweak your theme or add a plugin. The option for Threaded or Nested comments must be turned on in the Discussion menu under the Settings module in the WordPress dashboard.
You may have seen the WordPress blogs with replies to comments shown directly below another usually in a different color background to differentiate it. You might even see an example in this post eventually or just check out the post previous to this one to see what I mean. There are two ways to do achieve this, one is to edit your theme to add the functionality to it and the other is using a plugin. I usually advocate hard coding functionality in lieu of depending on a plugin, and I may even get around to doing it on this theme but in this case I opted for the lazy way by using a plugin.
The first plugin I tried was called Intense Debate. It has a lot of promise and options and while I can see where Intense Debate is trying to go I didn’t like the way it “took control” of my WordPress Comments. Intense Debate is more like a social comment site and the comments you make on other sites as well as the blogs you own can be administered directly on the Intense Debate site in your dashboard. It has a lot of potential and you may like it but I had difficulty editing comments and some were not showing up. What I consider a drawback is that the plugin is controlled and configured on the Intense Debate dashboard, not the WordPress dashboard. I also didn’t like the interface it added to my posts comment section, although you have the option to use your own style, but if I am going to go through the trouble of adding the style to a plugin I may as well just hard code the functionality into my theme and skip the plugin all together.
Another less obtrusive plugin for threaded comments is WordPress Thread Comment. That is what I am currently using as of this post and it seems to be doing what I want quite well. Unlike Intense Debate, the WordPress Thread Comment plugin is configured and controlled within the WordPress dashboard. It has a few options to configure like email notifications, and if you really want to tweak it the reply box HTML and CSS, among other things to tweak are available right in the plugins menu.
If you want to skip the plugins and add the comments enhancements directly to your theme then check out this post WordPress 2.7 Comments Enhancements
Remember the option for Threaded or Nested comments must be turned on in the Discussion menu under the Settings module in the WordPress dashboard.
Similar Posts:
- Adding WordPress Plugins From The Dashboard
- Best WordPress Plugins Maximize Your Blog
- WordPress Automatic Upgrade Plugin Problems
- WordPress Plugins How Many Are Too Many
- Install And Configure AdSense Deluxe WordPress Plugin
If you liked this post, feel free to leave a comment that is relevant to the post or subscribe to the feed and get future articles delivered to your feed reader.
Sorry but due to the spamming of a few all comments are moderated and will appear when approved and all drive-by comments will be deleted!
Comments
Hey Jeff, in wp 2.7, there’s threaded comment options but with my theme, it’s not enabled. Thanks for your post, I installed the plugin and now it works. Thanks a lot and now I’ll have even more comments!
Reply
Rick Replied:
April 8th, 2009 at 10:09 am
Jeff,
Are you still using WordPress Thread Comment? I’m wanting to add something like this to my blog and would like to know if you switched to something better.
Thank you.
Reply
Jeff Replied:
April 8th, 2009 at 2:53 pm
Yes Rick still using WP Thread Comment and that is what created this comment reply.
Reply
Very interesting plugin, I am still just beginning to learn WordPress and has not heard about such plugin. Tell me, where can I find more information?
Reply
Jeff Replied:
February 27th, 2009 at 8:57 am
Well I gave a few links in the post so try those or maybe…Google
Reply
nice plugin and tutorial
will have a go with my NEW blog later!
Reply
We recently spent the time to upgrade all the WordPress.com themes to support threaded comments natively, so if you’re looking for themes that do that sort of thing, or examples on how to do it, then check them out here: http://svn.automattic.com/wpcom-themes/
Reply
Thank you very much for the post because in one of my blog I use forte theme which is not supporting the plugin, but we can tweak the code and I just found it out through your post thanks again
Reply
Hi,
Thanks for the interesting post.
I love the threaded commenting system…………… : )
Reply
I tried Intense Debate too and I liked it but it did keep interfering with other plugins and all sorts of weird and wonderful things were happening so I had to disable it in the end.
I shall give this other plugin a try rather than touch the code, as in my case it’s probably safer. Thanks for bringing it to our attention – I found it by searching for ‘How to add threaded comments in WordPress’ via Google.
I’ll nip off and check out the rest of your blog now too
Nikki
Reply
Over the past 2 years I have neglected to install a blog on my site. At the time just didn’t see the value in blogging. To me it was just another task I would have to commit to.
Now that I have been smacked in the face and understand how blogging can and does add additional content to a site, it was recommended I go get Word Press.
After playing with it on and off for the past couple weeks and trying to find the plugins that provided the functionality I was looking for, I was so happy to stumble across your site here. A wealth of information is available in easy to understand terms. I think I am going to take it all in to discover exactly what direction I want to take my soon to be launched blog.
Thanks for taking the time to put together such a well informed site. Definitely one I will be following going forward.
Reply
I recently installed the WP threaded comments plugin to automatically notify commenters of a reply, but now my own replies to comments aren’t showing up on my blog. Is there something that needs to be changed in the settings to fix this? Thanks!
Reply
Jeff Replied:
April 12th, 2010 at 4:34 pm
I don’t offer support for or answer questions on plugins. Try the plugins author.
Reply
PLR Products Replied:
September 15th, 2010 at 8:58 am
This may be a problem with theme compatibility. Try installing a intense debate and see if that works.
Reply
Thanks so much for this helpful post. I was just stumped on how to get the replies to show nested and in order. This was just the perfect solution for me. Never thought of using a plugin.
Lavern
Reply
OMG! you are my savior ive been searching for hours and try to figure it out for a day to get a nested and reply comment. Although the new wordpress already have the nested and reply functions but what i dont get it some themes still overwrite this one. Thank god you have shown me the way to overcome this using plugin.I definitely bookmark your site!
Reply
Leave a comment
Drive-By comments will be deleted! Like "Thanks for sharing", "Nice post", or any other text that doesn't contribute to the discussion. If you ask a very specific question about your particular WordPress theme, it will probably be deleted. I can fix your WordPress site but for a price. If you ask a question like "Why don't my blog work right", it will be deleted. If you ask a question about your WordPress site without a leaving a link to it, it will be deleted. The point is to ask questions and or comment on the the actual content of the post, and to please use some common sense. All comments are moderated and will appear when approved. Thank you.